Misc trailer thoughts.Mpg and speed.
Open trailers don't have much aero drag unless you've got tires in an
overhead tire rack. Consider putting tires in your overhead tire rack
only if you really need to put them there. Otherwise, find some other
place to stash them. Enclosed trailers create lots of aero drag. Keep in
mind that force due to aero drag is proportional to the cube of speed.
So a small increase in speed makes a big difference.
Moving up from an open trailer to an enclosed trailer. I spent 5yrs
in an open trailer. In retrospect, I should have moved to an enclosed
trailer earlier. The increase in standard of living that comes with an
enclosed trailer is huge. You, all your tools, and the rest of your
gear, in an enclosed trailer sleep dry, warm, and comfortable. Sleeping
under a tarp thrown over the open trailer's tire rack got old on those
weekends that were cold and wet. I will always be grateful to the
various folks, especially Julio Palacio, for all the times they let me
sleep in their RV.
Size of enclosed trailer. Don't go smaller than 24'. A 20' trailer
has the same amount of aero drag and isn't much lighter. But the extra
4' of room will mean the difference between having 4' of space in front
of your car, and 4" of space in front of your car. The different in
"usability" is huge.
Tow capacity of your truck. Don't get too wrapped up in this. I used
to be a big believer in the school of thought that one should be very
conservative re. having "plenty of truck". Be we all get smarter as we
get older.
Tow capacity ratings are arrived at via a battery of tests. Those
tests don't necessarily reflect your values. For example, two of the
tests are directly associated with engine peak power. One test is a
short launch of a steep hill, and the other is a long pull up a steep
hill. The latter test also puts significant stress on the cooling
system.
When people get excited about tow capacity ratings, they talk about
having enough brakes and the truck being a "stable towing platform" a
product of truck weight, wheelbase, track width, and suspension design.
But what seems to actually set towing capacity isn't any of that. It's
the engine and the cooling system. This is one of those examples of
having to look behind the scenes and see what is really going on when
"common wisdom" is attempting to answer something for you.
As of Jan2018 my DD and tow vehicle for almost 4yrs has been a Ram 1500
Ecodiesel. It has the worst tow capacity in class. Yet, with a $100 air
bag kit helping it's rear springs, it's by far the best tow vehicle I've
ever had, and that includes an F-150 and and F-250 diesel.
The Ram 1500 Ecodiesel gets almost 2x the mpg of the F-150 when towing,
and compared to the F-250 diesel, the Ram's towing manners are much more
"sure" and "confidence inspiring". The damned F-250 was loud, stiffly
sprung, and no matter how much money I spent on it's suspension and
steering, required a lot of attention to drive because it tended to
wander. Towing with the F-250 I'd arrive already worn out by the stiff
suspension and roar of the engine and road noise. The Ram EcoD is like
towing with a big quiet sedan.
So if your trailer scheme sounds like it might be a little too heavy
for your truck, don't obsess over it. You may find that even if your
trailer a little heavy, your truck does a fabulous job towing. If,
however, your trailer is likely to be a couple thousand pounds too
heavy, then yes, maybe it's time for a bigger truck.
Differential ratios. Remember that tow ratings are all about your
truck drag racing off of the line. Often higher ration diffs are spec'd
to improve tow ratings, but that doesn't mean that the higher ratio diff
will actually be a factor in your towing.
Background. A higher ratio diff means more engine rpms at a given
mph.
Remember those drag race tests to establish tow rating. People often
talk as if a higher ratio diff means that their engine will turn more
rpms at all speeds. But the reality is that that your tranny will shift
whenever it hits the programmed shift points of rpm and load. So your
transmission is in total control of engine rpm, as long as it doesn't
run out of gears of the engine out of rpms. How often do you run out of
gears or rpms? Probably about never.
The tow rating tests runs out of gears or rpms 2x, and that's why the
diff changes the tow ratings. When the truck is "launched" in the tow
tests the tranny will downshift to 1st gear, since it has no lower gear,
the diff matters. The higher ratio diff will allow the tranny to run to
it's 2nd gear shift point faster.
In the long pull up the mountain test, a couple seconds after the
launch the engine will reach a steady state WOT doing as much pulling as
it's HP will allow. What ever gear it settles in, the engine will have
more hp in that gear at the higher rpm that the higher ratio diff
allows.
Big vs. little engines. If you tow up big hills then you might need a
bigger engine. But if your towing is mostly flat, then a small engine is
probably fine. The little 3.0 liter diesel in the EcoD only puts out
240hp and it does just fine, as long as I'm willing to slow down a bit
on big hills.
Gas vs. diesel. Diesel engines are inevitably a bit better on fuel,
but this is especially true when towing. So whereas my EcoD might be
rated at only 15% better mpg than an F-150 EcoBoost on the freeway, I
can expect probably 80% better mpg towing. Gas engines really suck fuel,
especially turbo engines, when push them harder then the couple dozen hp
needed to maintain freeway speeds, especially turbo engines.
Hp vs. torque. Don't get too wrapped up in torque #'s. Car magazines
have screwed up 60yrs of car enthusiasts re. what engine torque actually
means. Torque can be thought of as "hp at low rpm", which is
interesting, but since you can get more hp by just increasing rpm, "hp
at low rpm" is a lot more interesting to the marketing department then
it ought to be to you.
My diesel engine has 240hp. If your gas engine has 480hp, than
you honestly have 2x as much power as me. And "power" is just what it
sounds like...."power". It's the real deal. The "pulling power
comparison between our engines is pretty much done at that point and I
lose. But if, in an indication of my desperation, retort "but my engine has as much torque as yours",
than you know that car magazines have screwed me up too. Torque #'s are
just something one states if they don't have rpms and they're feeling
insecure. Diesels don't have much for rpms so diesel fans are easy meat
for car magazine writers that skipped HS physics.
Buying a used trailer. If you're low on funds, find the best used
trailer you can. New cheap trailers are usually crap and the money you
saved up front will be spent repairing your turd.
How to distinguish, when reading only marketing materials, between a
probably enclosed good trailer and a probably crappy enclosed trailer.
Good trailers are structurally more stout. Read carefully the spacing
and design of the reinforcing members under the floor, walls, and
ceiling. For example, 16" spacing between ceiling members means a
terrific trailer. Expect it to be heavier. 24" spacing between wall
members means a POS trailer.
Wood fiber board, instead of real wood, in the walls means crappy
trailer. Once that stuff gets wet, it falls apart.
Avoid 3500lb running gear in a lightweight trailer. Go HD for tires,
wheels, bearing, brakes, springs, and axles. If 3500 sounds barely good
enough, go to 5000lb. If 5000lb sounds barely good enough, go 6000 or
7500. Be conservative on this. All that shit is weak as heck.
Near as I can tell, all aluminum trailers are fabulous.